Ok So. The Thing About Jang Hayoung Is. Her Being Transgender Is Explicitly Meant To Represent Her Autonomy

ok so. the thing about jang hayoung is. her being transgender is explicitly meant to represent her autonomy as a person, and show how limited kim dokja's understanding of twsa is. like jang hayoung as the character kim dokja knows from twsa is perhaps the character who brings up the biggest questions re: character's personhood because kim dokja literally designed her, she's his oc. so we are forced to question her the most - are her traits and personality more attributable to her own choices, or are they entirely kim dokjas, for example. kim dokja knows everything about her, she was entirely his idea, and it leads to all sort of ethical dilemmas about exactly how much she can be considered her own person and what exactly their relationship to each other is.

or it would, if jang hayoung doesn't neatly sidestep all that 'does she even truly exist outside of kim dokja's perception of her' nonsense by looking firmly into the camera and saying yes, obviously. he doesn't even know im girl! so her gender is used to establish both her autonomy as a real human being AND demonstrate that kim dokja really doesn't know as much as he thinks he does, because hey it turns out even if you create them yourself people are sort of unknowable. i wonder if that relates to any of jang hayoung's themes about communication or something

anyway. these are two ideas firmly shoved into kim dokja's face by jang hayoung's gender identity, and they are two ideas he is deeply uncomfortable with. they force him to confront some thoughts he's been deeply suppressing and conflict heavily with his worldview. and unfortunately, sing shong decided to represent this discomfort with what jang hayoung's gender establishes by showing it as discomfort with jang hayoung's gender itself. that is not to say that kim dokja isn't being organically transphobic when he misgenders jang hayoung, just that that distaste for a conflict within his (gendered) worldview represents his distaste for a conflict within his (reader) worldview.

and this is bad. this is clearly a very transphobic and specifically trans misogynistic way to demonstrate this idea. its genuinely very distasteful to me that they decided to use a trans woman character like this. it casts a dark cloud over her character and the interesting things her transness represents - as well as one over the entire novel, not helped by the many other instances of transphobia we see. and i want to clarify that i do see it as bad and distasteful before i draw the following comparison, because as much as i love reclaiming homophobic and transphobic parts of the stories i like, i am deeply cautious of doing so without clearly acknowledging the harm they cause. also, i am a trans man, so i want to tread carefully when it comes to transphobia against trans women specifically.

but i do think its notable that sing shong clearly establish this link between transgenderism and autonomy and struggling to be understood within the story, and then give us a main character who's entire life has revolved around chasing those latter two things. a character who spends the arc jang hayoung stars in either in an opposite-sex-transformation or learning a 'woman only' sport as a 'man'. yoo joonghyuk, just like jang hayoung, is a character who challenges kim dokjas ideas about what it means to be a person vs character. yoo joonghyuk's entire arc is about chasing that autonomy that jang hayoung so clearly establishes through being transgender. yoo joonghyuk spends multiple arcs trying to get through to kim dokja that he does not understand yoo joonghyuk just because he happened to read about him in the way that jang hayoung clearly does when she declares herself a woman. this is a line that the story draws for me, not one im drawing on my own - this is a link between the autonomy yoo joonghyuk wants and the gender identity jang hayoung has that orv has already firmly established (although in a frequently transphobic way). and i think thats extremely interesting to acknowledge and explore, i think its a very clear part of yoo joonghyuk's character in this arc that never really goes away. and thats (part of) why yoo joonghyuk's end is [transition]

More Posts from Tatrinwhitewolf and Others

4 months ago
tatrinwhitewolf - TatrinWhiteWolf

4:35 PM LONDON TIME: I MADE IT 49/51 FUCK YEAH


Tags
5 years ago
#hug Makkachin Too
#hug Makkachin Too

#hug makkachin too

4 years ago
Our Fandom Has So Much Variety, So I Made A Test To Help People Gauge What Type Of Danny Phantom Fanfiction

our fandom has so much variety, so I made a test to help people gauge what type of Danny Phantom Fanfiction reader they are! so many options haha!

3 months ago

Kim Dokja and the concept of dying (major spoilers)

Warning: mentions of suicide, abusive acts and bullying, though it's only mentioned and not specified.

Okay, I've had this idea in my head since last night and probably a few days ago. But I think we all make fun or joke about how much Kim Dokja dies, and I sure as hell ain't gonna read 500+ chapters again just to count how many times he has died and reference what other characters felt towards Kim Dokja dying.

So, why did I bring this up?

Well the reason is simple. I think that Kim Dokja dies to show his love. I mean, it was practically his go to, he'd rather sacrifice himself than let others do it, even though they were 100% willing to die for him, Kim Dokja time and time again breaks his promises just to let them experience a new day.

Lee Sookyung, his mother, kick-started this whole affair. While she didn't die when Kim Dokja killed their abuser, she did ruin her life and made it unable for her to go back to living a life with Kim Dokja. Effectively, to Kim Dokja, the mother he knew died at the same time his father died.

He also had a shitty life and none of his classmates nor relatives were sympathetic nor empathetic at all, hell when he moves in with some relatives I bet they don't even care about him or just abuse him. His classmates hurt him, his teachers turn a blind eye to him and reporters hound him for their money source. The whole world was telling him he was "useless and unimportant" and even Lee Sookyung couldn't comfort Kim Dokja as a mother anymore, I think she knows she lost the right to be Kim Dokja's mother the moment she let her book out, effectively not only ruining her but her son's life.

To both of them, they both died on that same day.

And when the Alter Han Sooyoung saw Kim Dokja's comatose body after he jumped and realized just how much the book she roasted was the only book that made Kim Dokja get up to live another day, even when the world told him "Die, you're nothing but a murderer's son" she kept giving him that awful story she hated "Three Ways to Survive a Ruined World" because deep down, she wanted to have a reader like Kim Dokja who talked to her, read her work and became the only thing letting him live.

Then the dying part.

The first time we see Kim Dokja die was during that King fighting where he managed to become a Salvation King(?). He died the first time and told no one he would come back or maybe assure them he would, because at that time he was living in the world of his novel. The novel that was created for him, and the people in his life and in the novel blend together making him unaware where his reality started and ended. He told no one because, as much as he can admit, he didn't or couldn't trust them, because the people back then would hurt him and tell him to die. Why else would he have committed suicide?

And as the book continues, we see Kim Dokja starting to piece together that people genuinely care for him, that he saved someone even for his own personal benefits and sees that even though they know, they still want to prove themselves. He sees how his mere existence impacts people to be stronger, to be better, and he feels, for the first time, wanting to protect.

During 45th turn (was it 45th..?) Shin Yoosung. Kim Dokja wouldn't let her die and kept doing the impossible to free her and give her a second chance, maybe he saw himself in her and wanted her to have a chance of happiness and freedom that the young Kim Dokja desperately pleaded. Kim Dokja found respite in his novel and now he wants to free Shin Yoosung.

Don't get me started when Yoo Sangah had to die, Lee Sookyung became desperately ill due to her ability or Lee Hyunsung's soul being yeet off to the Land of Oz. He kept going to them and basically screaming "IF YOU SAY I CAN'T DIE! THEN YOU CAN'T DIE NO MATTER WHAT!!!" challenging the impossible, fighting constellations and gambling with his life at stake for his companions.

As the series progress so does his self destructive habits. He will continuously kill himself if it means that the people he starts to love will have a chance to live in this fucked up world. He's been twisted and hammered down by life ever since he was young and no one ever cared for him... Except for the author of the novel, tls123, Alter Han Sooyoung. That extends to the novel.

Now that he has people he cares for, Kin Dokja doesn't know how to say "I love you", doesn't know how to show affection and that just baffles him so he pushes away those emotional needs and quickly tries to ruin the Star Stream. For me, if he destroys the Star Stream, this will be his saying of "I love you" to his companions because by then, everyone is free, nobody needs to die or hurt themselves over a scenario.

Nobody will be strung along for the amusement of constellations.

And since Kim Dokja always dies...

That's his way of saying "I love you" even when it guarantees giving his companions trauma and fears for him. Because Lee Sookyung's final act of motherhood for Kim Dokja was her ruining and killing herself as Kim Dokja's mother and becoming a "murderer", lying to not only everyone in this world and her son, but to herself. This was her final saying of "I love you" to Kim Dokja as she was dragged away to prison.

Kim Dokja, deep down, believes he is unimportant even though he assures himself he is with his knowledge. But when he sees a situation where even he can't find a solution, he will die for them. He won't hesitate to jump into danger if it means saving the only people who loves and cares for him.

The most telling is during the Demon King Selection. Where Kim Dokja's prophesied demise is by the hands of his "most beloved/loved person" and when Kim Dokja found out and when he saw Yoo Joonghyuk ready to sacrifice himself.

I wonder, if he ever felt the flashes of guilt pass through his eyes, because even back then he knew that Yoo Joonghyuk suffered 1863rd turns to keep one reader alive, and that's why he tells Yoo Joonghyuk to live even when Kim Dokja is the most hypocritical person in the world.

Because, to Kim Dokja, Yoo Joonghyuk was the only person who gave Kim Dokja a reason to wake up and not jump.

When he became the Demon King, he didn't attack. He would watch his party cry and kill him and even then he seemed happy. He would eventually come back but in that moment, this incident must have finally shot a bullet in his head that people would cry when he died.

And that led him to want to live. Live and be beside his companions, his family.

This then shows in the Remake of Journey to the West where he made a deal with the Wenny King or Secretive Plotter to become an Outer God if he could not fulfill the requirements in exchange for him living. And when he finally became an Outer God, you could see how much he wants to be with Lee Gilyoung, Shin Yoosung, Yoo Joonghyuk and everyone else. He keeps pursuing such dangerous options so that his companions won't have to do it. He'll step on thorny roads so that his companions can live.

And that even extends to the very final scenes in the book. Two key points:

A.) Kim Dokja splitting himself up and leaving himself behind in the subway.

B.) Kim Dokja going in a coma.

Both are the same in the prospect that the world where his family will live in is going to collapse if nobody dreams for them.

Why Kim Dokja was ready to give his family an avatar with 49% of his memory so that even in spirit, he could be with them. And he was selfish because, as heavily stated before, they were after all, the first people that cared for him. So he held on to 2% of their journey close to his chest as he headed to his death in that lonely subway.

Why Kim Dokja split himself far and wide just so that his companions wouldn't destroy the world together. A suicide mission. He must have been shocked that they loved him that much to disregard the entire universe for him and felt helpless. Because even when they managed to get a hold on him... They would perish and he would be alone.

What was his final moments as he rapidly split himself up, his guilt as he imagined their faces one last time and his helpless laughter as he couldn't believe how preposterous his companions were.

His happiness that someone cared for him which then turned to fear that they would die.

His sadness that he couldn't stay with them and his anger at them for not being satisfied with 49%... His shame when he clung to 2%... His promise he keeps breaking.

He wants to live, even during those days in the scenario where he stayed with Kim Dokja's Company, wants to live with them and live in a world that's slowly healing.

So he'll take any chances to let them live and maybe hope, in this twisted world, he can live with them.

So he sleeps as the Most Ancient Dream and dreams them to be happy and waits to wake up.

That's why the ending is so bittersweet yet beautiful.

Because the Most Ancient Dream woke up to the dreams of his loved ones crashing through the door and turning to reality.

Because even Kim Dokja can love someone. He's no longer Alone nor a Reader.

He's at home.

4 years ago
VENTI’s Idle Animations
VENTI’s Idle Animations
VENTI’s Idle Animations
VENTI’s Idle Animations

VENTI’s idle animations

4 years ago

What’s your opinion on jiraiya? Personally I detest him

Funny you should ask ‘cause I’m readying chapter 29 for publishing as we speak, and he just happens to make his first apparition here.

I dislike him and always have. In fact I think he’s the only “nice” character I disliked from the start - for most of the others it came when I was older and analyzing Naruto deeper than I had as a kid. But Jiraiya never worked on me. First of all, because the pervert trope is one of the things I dislike the most in manga and anime culture. This whole “old man perving after women, trying to see them naked and talking about boobs all the time” really isn’t what draws me to the media. Especially because it’s never criticized in any way - he gets called out on it and punched on occasion, but it’s not seen as a major character flaw, the way it should. I read back on his first meeting with Naruto for chapter 29 and damn. Naruto uses Sexy Meta to convince him to train him, and he tries to bargain for him to stay in that form the whole time… NOT cute and funny. This is just gross.

Generally speaking he is unlikeable to me. Irresponsible, immature, caring only about his immediate pleasure, kind of mean at times too… It’s been said before but the scene where he convinces Naruto to entrust him with his hard-worn money, only to spend it all in women and alcohol? Like, wow. That’s top-notch asshole move, there’s nothing excusable about it, and even as a kid it made me very uncomfortable, seeing that it was pretty much swept under the rug.

And well, getting into meta and over-analyzing Naruto really doesn’t paint him in a better light, because he’s the boy’s fucking godfather and he abandoned him just like the rest. Even if he was spying around, even if he had missions and whatnot, he should have checked on the kid, there’s really no excuse for it. And again the issue is that it’s not one. Just like the Sandaime, his actions are never put into question. It feeds into the general issue of no one ever fucking apologizing to Naruto for failing him and for the shit they put him though, and Naruto never resenting anyone either, something that’s I’m forever bitter about (and made me write 240k of fanfic lol). As it is, his death didn’t work for me as well as it’s supposed to in the narrative, because like… I really never felt like Naruto was that attached to him, and had any reason to? And I surely wasn’t attached either. I was sad Naruto lost him, but at the same time… Meh.

I enjoy his backstory with Tsunade and Orochimaru a lot more. I like their relationship and the tragedy behind it, how they failed utterly and completely to save each other. And I’m partial to the whole Ame Kids Debable I guess, even if how could the village let him stay in a warzone to teach foreign kids for what many years is beyond me. Don’t shinobi have like, things to do? Duties to uphold? Also I’m on the wikia and I just saw that when he parted with them he told Konan she’d grow to be beautiful, and to come see him when she turned eighteen… Why man, why.

And this whole prophecy child also does very little to me? But that has more to do with that plotline in general, that was pretty useless and unnecessary imo. So yeah, it’s safe to say I don’t like him.

BUT he’s still part of the story and still has a role to play in my fic, and I don’t bash character cause I don’t. So I’ll have to find a way to make him okay for me to write… We’ll see how I fare haha.

Sorry for the rant, seems like I had things to say on the matter. Thanks for asking though, I’m always ready to give a lengthy opinion on anything at any time :p

4 years ago
The Moment I Saw Her Design, I Immediately Wished Keikain Yura Would Wear The Same

The moment I saw her design, I immediately wished Keikain Yura would wear the same

archiveofourown.org
An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works

Tags
4 years ago
When Your Fridge Is Filled To The Brim With Ice Creams

When your fridge is filled to the brim with ice creams


Tags
  • narke
    narke reblogged this · 2 days ago
  • alpha-nymeria
    alpha-nymeria liked this · 1 week ago
  • the-bitter-ocean
    the-bitter-ocean liked this · 1 week ago
  • crookedtidalwaves
    crookedtidalwaves reblogged this · 1 week ago
  • crookedtidalwaves
    crookedtidalwaves liked this · 1 week ago
  • haretic-smith
    haretic-smith reblogged this · 2 weeks ago
  • narke
    narke liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • ffroggyhhat
    ffroggyhhat reblogged this · 3 weeks ago
  • a-random-dragon
    a-random-dragon liked this · 3 weeks ago
  • haretic-smith
    haretic-smith liked this · 1 month ago
  • dreamsevens
    dreamsevens reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • imageofvoid
    imageofvoid reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • forgets-people-exist
    forgets-people-exist liked this · 1 month ago
  • gumball-gleam
    gumball-gleam reblogged this · 1 month ago
  • cryptologicalmystic
    cryptologicalmystic liked this · 2 months ago
  • ariel2art
    ariel2art liked this · 2 months ago
  • rockrozma
    rockrozma liked this · 2 months ago
  • gautierprotectionsquad
    gautierprotectionsquad reblogged this · 2 months ago
  • kelsgoldenoj
    kelsgoldenoj liked this · 2 months ago
  • tatrinwhitewolf
    tatrinwhitewolf reblogged this · 2 months ago
  • chaoticgremlinbrainspace
    chaoticgremlinbrainspace reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • chaoticgremlinbrainspace
    chaoticgremlinbrainspace liked this · 3 months ago
  • yuucandoit
    yuucandoit reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • the-fandom-panda
    the-fandom-panda liked this · 3 months ago
  • bs-03
    bs-03 liked this · 3 months ago
  • lesblep
    lesblep reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • akwertyy
    akwertyy liked this · 3 months ago
  • meowmeowmeow83
    meowmeowmeow83 liked this · 3 months ago
  • ihavenotfallenyet
    ihavenotfallenyet reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • anaander
    anaander liked this · 3 months ago
  • twotiredforthis
    twotiredforthis liked this · 3 months ago
  • jemthebookworm
    jemthebookworm reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • jemthebookworm
    jemthebookworm liked this · 3 months ago
  • quills-and-daggers
    quills-and-daggers liked this · 3 months ago
  • ikusayu-no-hana
    ikusayu-no-hana reblogged this · 3 months ago
  • oneactplays
    oneactplays liked this · 4 months ago
  • fabulaescrita
    fabulaescrita liked this · 4 months ago
  • axolotlanarchy
    axolotlanarchy liked this · 4 months ago
  • orv-stuff-for-you
    orv-stuff-for-you reblogged this · 4 months ago
  • 999murimdumplings
    999murimdumplings reblogged this · 4 months ago
  • nekomim1
    nekomim1 liked this · 4 months ago
  • ihateyukanda
    ihateyukanda liked this · 4 months ago
  • hearthomelesbian
    hearthomelesbian reblogged this · 4 months ago
  • lemongrasslesbian
    lemongrasslesbian liked this · 4 months ago
  • imjustheretoreadbsdanthology
    imjustheretoreadbsdanthology liked this · 4 months ago
  • mccromy
    mccromy liked this · 4 months ago
tatrinwhitewolf - TatrinWhiteWolf
TatrinWhiteWolf

Laid back and kind of mean, but feelings are very delicate

66 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags