This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story

This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story
This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story
This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story
This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story
This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story
This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story
This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story
This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story
This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story
This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story

This One Thought Experiment Shows Why Special Relativity Isn’t The Full Story

“In Einstein’s initial formulation of General Relativity way back in 1916, he mentioned the gravitational redshift (and blueshift) of light as a necessary consequence of his new theory, and the third classical test, after the precession of Mercury’s perihelion (already known at the time) and the deflection of starlight by a gravitational source (discovered during a total solar eclipse in 1919).

Although a thought experiment is an extremely powerful tool, practical experiments didn’t catch up until 1959, where the Pound-Rebka experiment finally measured a gravitational redshift/blueshift directly. Yet just by invoking the idea that energy must be conserved, and a basic understanding of particle physics and gravitational fields, we can learn that light must change its frequency in a gravitational field.”

If a photon flies through space towards Earth, it must gain energy and become bluer in nature as it approaches Earth’s surface. This idea, of a gravitational redshift or blueshift, dictates how a photon must change in energy in the presence of a gravitational field. Yet this effect, which only exists in General Relativity, could have been predicted as soon as special relativity was discovered by one simple thought experiment: to consider a particle-antiparticle pair dropped from high above the surface of the Earth, but to let the annihilation occur at varying locations.

If you considered that, you’d immediately realize how special relativity was insufficient for describing our Universe! Come learn how to reason it out for yourself today!

More Posts from Ocrim1967 and Others

5 years ago
Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth
Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth
Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth
Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth
Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth
Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth
Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth
Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth
Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth
Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth

Happy 230th Birthday, Enceladus, Our Solar System’s Greatest Hope For Life Beyond Earth

“It is still a complete unknown whether Earth is the only world in the Solar System to house any form of life: past or present. Venus and Mars may have been Earth-like for a billion years or more, and life could have arisen there early on. Frozen worlds with subsurface oceans, like Enceladus, Europa, Triton or Pluto, are completely different from Earth’s present environment, but have the same raw ingredients that could potentially lead to life as well.

Are water, energy, and the right molecules all we need for life to arise? Finding even the most basic organisms (or even the precursor components of organisms) anyplace else in the Universe would lead to a scientific revolution. A single discovered cell in the geysers of Enceladus would be the most momentous discovery of the 21st century. With the recent demise of Cassini, on the 230th anniversary of Enceladus’ discovery, the possibility of finding the incredible compels us to go back. May we be bold enough to make it so.”

On this date in 1789, William Herschel, armed with the most powerful telescope known to humanity at the time (you can get a lot of grant money when you discover the planet Uranus and name it after the King), discovered a relatively small moon of Saturn just 500 kilometers across: Enceladus. For some 200 years, Enceladus was never seen as more than a single pixel across, until the Voyager probes flew by it. What they revealed was a remarkable, unique world in all the Solar System. Now that the Cassini mission is complete, we can look back at all we know about this world, and all the signs point to a remarkable story: there’s a subsurface ocean, possibly suitable as a home for undersea life.

Is Enceladus truly our Solar System’s best hope for life beyond Earth? That’s debatable, but there’s every reason to be hopeful. Come get the story here.

5 years ago
What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?
What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?
What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?
What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?
What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?
What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?
What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?
What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?
What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?
What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?

What Is The Smallest Possible Distance In The Universe?

“At present, there is no way to predict what’s going to happen on distance scales that are smaller than about 10-35 meters, nor on timescales that are smaller than about 10-43 seconds. These values are set by the fundamental constants that govern our Universe. In the context of General Relativity and quantum physics, we can go no farther than these limits without getting nonsense out of our equations in return for our troubles.

It may yet be the case that a quantum theory of gravity will reveal properties of our Universe beyond these limits, or that some fundamental paradigm shifts concerning the nature of space and time could show us a new path forward. If we base our calculations on what we know today, however, there’s no way to go below the Planck scale in terms of distance or time. There may be a revolution coming on this front, but the signposts have yet to show us where it will occur.”

If you went down to smaller and smaller distance scales, you might imagine that you’ll start to see the Universe more clearly and in higher resolution. You’ll be able to hone in on the fundamental properties of nature, and glean more information the deeper you go. This is true, but only up to a point. Beyond that, you start running into the inescapable quantum rules that govern the Universe, and that means there’s a fundamental scale at which our best laws of physics cannot be trusted any longer.

That scale is the Planck scale, and for distances, it corresponds to about 10^-35 meters. It really is a problem for physics, and it’s high time you understood why.

6 years ago

Google Classroom FINALLY lets you add a “Materials” section under “Classwork”

Literally two days ago they added the ability to add a new kind of post under a Classwork topic. “Materials” (instead of Assignment or Question) 

This is your workaround for losing the “About” page. Set up a topic called “About” or “Resources”, then add a “Materials” post under that topic. Boom, done!

image

ALSO, if you created a Google Classroom before the update, and only have the Stream and People pages, you can now manually add a Classwork page by clicking the grey question mark in the bottom left corner, then selecting “Add Classwork page”.

image

Try it out, today! 

Your Friendly Neighborhood Google for Education Certified Trainer, 

-WCT

5 years ago

Water, Water Everywhere; We Track Drops to Drink!

When we think about what makes a planet habitable, we’re often talking about water. With abundant water in liquid, gas (vapor) and solid (ice) form, Earth is a highly unusual planet. Almost 70% of our home planet’s surface is covered in water!

image

But about 97% of Earth’s water is salty – only a tiny amount is freshwater: the stuff humans, pets and plants need to survive.

Water on our planet is constantly moving, and not just geographically. Water shifts phases from ice to water to vapor and back, moving through the planet’s soils and skies as it goes.

That’s where our satellites come in.

image

Look at the Midwestern U.S. this spring, for example. Torrential rain oversaturated the soil and overflowed rivers, which caused severe flooding, seen by Landsat.

image

Our satellites also tracked a years-long drought in California. Between 2013 and 2014, much of the state turned brown, without visible green.  

image

It’s not just rain. Where and when snow falls – and melts – is changing, too. The snow that falls and accumulates on the ground is called snowpack, which eventually melts and feeds rivers used for drinking water and crop irrigation. When the snow doesn’t fall, or melts too early, communities go without water and crops don’t get watered at the right time.

image

Even when water is available, it can become contaminated by blooms of phytoplankton, like cyanobacteria . Also known as blue-green algae, these organisms can make humans sick if they drink the water. Satellites can help track algae from space, looking for the brightly colored blooms against blue water.

image
image

Zooming even farther back, Earth’s blue water is visible from thousands of miles away. The water around us makes our planet habitable and makes our planet shine blue among the darkness of space.

image

Knowing where the water is, and where it’s going, helps people make better decisions about how to manage it. Earth’s climate is changing rapidly, and freshwater is moving as a result. Some places are getting drier and some are getting much, much wetter. By predicting droughts and floods and tracking blooms of algae, our view of freshwater around the globe helps people manage their water.

Make sure to follow us on Tumblr for your regular dose of space: http://nasa.tumblr.com.

6 years ago
At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants
At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants
At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants
At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants
At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants
At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants
At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants
At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants
At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants
At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants

At Last, Scientists Have Found The Galaxy’s Missing Exoplanets: Cold Gas Giants

“By using the same instrument and leaving virtually no long-term gaps in the data, long-term, precise Doppler measurements finally became possible. A total of five brand new planets, one confirmation of a suggested planet, and three updated planets were announced in this latest study, bringing the total number of Jupiter-or-larger planets beyond the Jupiter-Sun distance up to 26. It shows us what we’d always hoped for: that our Solar System isn’t so unusual in the Universe; it’s just difficult to observe and detect planets like the ones we have.”

We’ve long suspected that there was nothing special about our Solar System; that Sun-like stars should have a wide variety of planets around them, including many of the types of worlds found orbiting our Sun. However, owing to the difficulty in making the kinds of measurements that would reveal them to us, our work has revealed a sample of planets biased towards two types of planets: the short-period worlds and the well-separated, high-mass worlds. Planets like Jupiter or Saturn were elusive for so long. But now, owing to research programs dedicated to monitoring nearby stars on decadal timescales, we’ve revealed a remarkable number of these worlds, many of which are now candidates for future direct imaging surveys.

The missing gas giants of the Universe, including worlds like the ones actually found orbiting our Sun, are finally within reach. Here’s how we’ve revealed them at last!

6 years ago
If The Moon Were Replaced With Some Of Our Planets (at Night)
If The Moon Were Replaced With Some Of Our Planets (at Night)
If The Moon Were Replaced With Some Of Our Planets (at Night)
If The Moon Were Replaced With Some Of Our Planets (at Night)
If The Moon Were Replaced With Some Of Our Planets (at Night)
If The Moon Were Replaced With Some Of Our Planets (at Night)
If The Moon Were Replaced With Some Of Our Planets (at Night)
If The Moon Were Replaced With Some Of Our Planets (at Night)

If the Moon were replaced with some of our planets (at night)

Image credit: yeti dynamics

5 years ago
Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?
Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?
Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?
Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?
Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?
Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?
Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?
Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?
Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?
Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?

Ask Ethan: Why Do Gravitational Waves Travel Exactly At The Speed Of Light?

We know that the speed of electromagnetic radiation can be derived from Maxwell’s equation[s] in a vacuum. What equations (similar to Maxwell’s - perhaps?) offer a mathematical proof that Gravity Waves must travel [at the] speed of light?

If you were to somehow make the Sun disappear, you would still see its emitted light for 8 minutes and 20 seconds: the amount of time it takes light to travel from the Sun to the Earth across 150,000,000 km of space. But what about gravitation? Would the Earth continue to orbit where the Sun was for that same 8 minutes and 20 seconds, or would it fly off in a straight line immediately?

There are two ways to look at this puzzle: theoretically and experimentally/observationally. From a theoretical point of view, this represents one of the most profound differences from Newton’s gravitation to Einstein’s, and demonstrates what a revolutionary leap General Relativity was. Observationally, we only had indirect measurements until 2017, where we determined the speed of gravity and the speed of light were equal to 15 significant digits!

Gravitational waves do travel at the speed of light, which equals the speed of gravity to a better precision than ever. Here’s how we know.

6 years ago

I love flowers 💐❤️

image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
image
6 years ago
A High-definition Video Camera Outside The Space Station Captured Stark And Sobering Views Of Hurricane

A high-definition video camera outside the space station captured stark and sobering views of Hurricane Florence, a Category 4 storm. Image Credit: ESA/NASA–A. Gerst

A High-definition Video Camera Outside The Space Station Captured Stark And Sobering Views Of Hurricane

The scene is a late-spring afternoon in the Amazonis Planitia region of northern Mars. The view covers an area about four-tenths of a mile (644 meters) across. North is toward the top. The length of the dusty whirlwind’s shadow indicates that the dust plume reaches more than half a mile (800 meters) in height. The plume is about 30 yards or meters in diameter. Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/Univ. of Arizona

A High-definition Video Camera Outside The Space Station Captured Stark And Sobering Views Of Hurricane

A false-color image of the Great Red Spot of Jupiterfrom Voyager 1. The white oval storm directly below the Great Red Spot has the approximate diameter of Earth. NASA, Caltech/JPL

A High-definition Video Camera Outside The Space Station Captured Stark And Sobering Views Of Hurricane

The huge storm (great white spot) churning through the atmosphere in Saturn’s northern hemisphere overtakes itself as it encircles the planet in this true-color view from NASA’s Cassini spacecraft. Credit: Cassini Imaging Team, SSI, JPL, ESA, NASA; Color Composite: Jean-Luc Dauvergne

A High-definition Video Camera Outside The Space Station Captured Stark And Sobering Views Of Hurricane

The spinning vortex of Saturn’s north polar storm resembles a deep red rose of giant proportions surrounded by green foliage in this false-color image from NASA’s Cassini spacecraft. Measurements have sized the eye at 1,250 miles (2,000 kilometers) across with cloud speeds as fast as 330 miles per hour (150 meters per second). This image is among the first sunlit views of Saturn’s north pole captured by Cassini’s imaging cameras. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/SSI

A High-definition Video Camera Outside The Space Station Captured Stark And Sobering Views Of Hurricane

Colorized infrared image of Uranus obtained on August 6, 2014, with adaptive optics on the 10-meter Keck telescope; white spots are large storms. Image credit: Imke de Pater, University of California, Berkeley / Keck Observatory images.

A High-definition Video Camera Outside The Space Station Captured Stark And Sobering Views Of Hurricane

Neptune’s Great Dark Spot, a large anticyclonic storm similar to Jupiter’s Great Red Spot, observed by NASA’s Voyager 2 spacecraft in 1989. Credit: NASA / Jet Propulsion Lab

A High-definition Video Camera Outside The Space Station Captured Stark And Sobering Views Of Hurricane

This true color image captured by NASA’S Cassini spacecraft before a distant flyby of Saturn’s moon Titan on June 27, 2012, shows a south polar vortex, or a swirling mass of gas around the pole in the atmosphere. Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/Space Science Institute

A High-definition Video Camera Outside The Space Station Captured Stark And Sobering Views Of Hurricane

This artist’s concept shows what the weather might look like on cool star-like bodies known as brown dwarfs. These giant balls of gas start out life like stars, but lack the mass to sustain nuclear fusion at their cores, and instead, fade and cool with time.

New research from NASA’s Spitzer Space Telescope suggests that most brown dwarfs are racked with colossal storms akin to Jupiter’s famous “Great Red Spot.” These storms may be marked by fierce winds, and possibly lightning. The turbulent clouds might also rain down molten iron, hot sand or salts – materials thought to make up the cloud layers of brown dwarfs.

Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/University of Western Ontario/Stony Brook University

A High-definition Video Camera Outside The Space Station Captured Stark And Sobering Views Of Hurricane

In this image, the nightmare world of HD 189733 b is the killer you never see coming. To the human eye, this far-off planet looks bright blue. But any space traveler confusing it with the friendly skies of Earth would be badly mistaken. The weather on this world is deadly. Its winds blow up to 5,400 mph (2 km/s) at seven times the speed of sound, whipping all would-be travelers in a sickening spiral around the planet. And getting caught in the rain on this planet is more than an inconvenience; it’s death by a thousand cuts. This scorching alien world possibly rains glass—sideways—in its howling winds. The cobalt blue color comes not from the reflection of a tropical ocean, as on Earth, but rather a hazy, blow-torched atmosphere containing high clouds laced with silicate particles. Image Credit: ESO/M. Kornmesser

6 years ago
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 
Working Too Hard, Feeling Overwhelmed By Family Responsibilities, Or Dealing With An Ongoing Challenge? 

Working too hard, feeling overwhelmed by family responsibilities, or dealing with an ongoing challenge? 

Maybe it’s time to turn your attention back to yourself and to your own self-care. Although we often brush it aside, self-care is not optional if you want to be happy and healthy.

  • pacogabby
    pacogabby liked this · 1 year ago
  • eisbar777
    eisbar777 liked this · 1 year ago
  • aikido85
    aikido85 liked this · 3 years ago
  • toshawater
    toshawater liked this · 4 years ago
  • ktsmilez1
    ktsmilez1 liked this · 5 years ago
  • turtonator
    turtonator liked this · 5 years ago
  • hee-sham
    hee-sham reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • turtlebugtot
    turtlebugtot reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • turtlebugtot
    turtlebugtot liked this · 5 years ago
  • bigdaddy1854sblog-blog
    bigdaddy1854sblog-blog reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • paul-2250
    paul-2250 liked this · 5 years ago
  • ghostlypiegardenpizza-blog
    ghostlypiegardenpizza-blog liked this · 5 years ago
  • marspace27-blog
    marspace27-blog liked this · 5 years ago
  • holywombatpandaclam
    holywombatpandaclam liked this · 5 years ago
  • your-crazy-8thgrade-neighbo-blog
    your-crazy-8thgrade-neighbo-blog liked this · 5 years ago
  • legendarytreedeanrebel-blog
    legendarytreedeanrebel-blog liked this · 5 years ago
  • doyougotroomforonemore
    doyougotroomforonemore liked this · 5 years ago
  • solpq
    solpq liked this · 5 years ago
  • introverted-astrophile
    introverted-astrophile reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • anonimousplayer
    anonimousplayer liked this · 5 years ago
  • satria-widya-nto
    satria-widya-nto liked this · 5 years ago
  • intany
    intany liked this · 5 years ago
  • birdflu2k11
    birdflu2k11 reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • poporano
    poporano liked this · 5 years ago
  • fabifuyumi
    fabifuyumi liked this · 5 years ago
  • sanjerodo
    sanjerodo liked this · 5 years ago
  • loser0downer
    loser0downer liked this · 5 years ago
  • coffee-and-vroomvroom
    coffee-and-vroomvroom reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • casualnerdwagonpony-blog
    casualnerdwagonpony-blog liked this · 5 years ago
  • ocrim1967
    ocrim1967 reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • ocrim1967
    ocrim1967 liked this · 5 years ago
  • de-la-mancha
    de-la-mancha reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • yominimamente
    yominimamente liked this · 5 years ago
  • cr--ed
    cr--ed liked this · 5 years ago
  • jpaul
    jpaul liked this · 5 years ago
  • jpaul-science
    jpaul-science reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • nandoaoct
    nandoaoct liked this · 5 years ago
  • ad-astra-per-aspera-80
    ad-astra-per-aspera-80 reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • ad-astra-per-aspera-80
    ad-astra-per-aspera-80 liked this · 5 years ago
  • new-great-age-of-discovery
    new-great-age-of-discovery reblogged this · 5 years ago
ocrim1967 - Senza titolo
Senza titolo

185 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags