Hi I Have A Theory! Ok So We Know That UT Mourns Vincent's Death So What If He Was Trying To Bring Him

Hi I have a theory! Ok so we know that UT mourns Vincent's death so what if he was trying to bring him back as bizarre doll? We know his body was burnt to ashes heck UT said it himself but if he had cinematic record and if he had supplement dead body MAYBE he could bring him back!! I know this theory has holes but it makes sense! Maybe UT needs a large amounts of blood for him to bring him into life! Still Idk if Sirius is Vincent amd that Ut suceeded at this point... what do you think thou?

Hi, sorry for my super late reply!!

Mmm, it’s a possibility but, personally I do not think UT is trying to bring back Vincent as a bizarre doll, or more precisely, maybe he might have wanted to revive him, but in the end couldn’t.

For one, UT said that Vincent’s body was burnt to the core, meaning that there’s nothing left of him. Idk, it was never really confirmed but I had always thought that Cinematic Records are attached to the brain (hence, all the stitches on the forehead of Bizarre Dolls and the fact that you have to smash their head to defeat them), so if that were indeed the case, Vincent’s cinematic records must have disappeared in the fire along with his body (his head).

Also, as I explained in this post, Undertaker’s line goes

“Poor thing, even the marrows of his bones were burnt. With that way of dying, … can’t …. anymore”.

The sentence was incomplete, so we don’t know 100% what he was trying to say, but the sentence structure heavily implies that he must have meant something along “Vincent can’t be revived/transformed into a bizarre doll anymore”. And right after that, he continues with

“Ah, but… there still is an “Earl Phantomhvie”, isn’t there“.

I know YP and the online scanlation translated this phrase as ”The ‘Earl Phantomhive’ still lives/is still with us“ but I strongly disagree with both translations and think they are a bit misleading because UT neither mentioned the word "live” nor “be with us” in the original language, but simply said “there is/exists (いる)”. To me it definitely sounded like he’s talking about “another” Earl Phantomhive who can replace Vincent for Undertaker’s goal (whatever that might be) and at the moment I think it is very likely that that specific “Earl Phantomhive” he was talking about in ch105 was

real Ciel.

And imo Violet’s reaction in ch125 pretty much confirmed that real Ciel is Sirius (Violet knew that Sirius looks like our Ciel since he was his blood donor and that’s why he was so scared when he saw our Ciel because he mistook him for Lord Sirius/real Ciel for a moment).

So personally, I do not think Undertaker would be able to revive Vincent in any form (be it a clone or a bizarre doll) and I assume that’s the very reason why UT cried in ch105 in the first place.