I Think I Read A Post Of You That Said Western Leftist Can't Write Conservative Religious Women Without

i think i read a post of you that said western leftist can't write conservative religious women without reducing them to being brainwashed or insecure. as a western leftist I'm curious how you would have written alicent for hotd?

You mean how would I personally rewrite Alicent's character? Or how I would have liked to see GRRM's Alicent written in the show?

Either way; I'd say: Western leftists can't write a traditionally religious woman unless she's a hypocrite, brainwashed, or actively using religion to cope or to feel superior. They can't write a religious woman who genuinely and intellectually believes in and is devoted to her own religious conventions and ideals. And when they do - which is very rare - they always feel the need to attach a moral or intellectual judgment on her. She must always be "lesser". Unless she's pagan and they can co-opt her paganism to uplift their own "progressive" ideology 🙄

Anyways, I hated how they made Alicent cling to her faith as a means of "repentance" in the show. She should have clung to her faith as a means of resistance. Of claiming her identity and power back.

This will give the "Green Dress" moment and the "Where is duty? Where is sacrifice?" moment real meaning.

It's not that she can't sincerely believe in her religion and still subconsciously use it to heal her psychological and emotional wounds. It can happen. It's not mutually exclusive. But her ability to use her religion to heal should be originated from and motivated by her sincere belief in her religion.

The Faith of the Seven was always the hard and the soft power that kept the megalomanic, blood-supremacist Targs in check after they conquered Westeros. The Targs were forced to compromise and adapt to Westeros instead of forcing Westeros to be assimilated or fully subjected to Targ culture and religion.

Alicent's ambition should have reflected this spirit. Her need to have her son crowned as King should have been her own way to keep the Targs in more chains. To mold the Targ dynasty to benefit her and her children and Westeros as a whole.

What better way for an oppressed woman to feel liberated than to have the power to put her oppressors in chains? and to have the freedom to live by her own conventions and ideals without sacrificing her dignity and sanity?

More Posts from Sielutonlampikana and Others

2 years ago

I want to be excited for the live action Little Mermaid so badly

The Little Mermaid is my favorite Disney movie. Anyone who knows me knows I'm obsessed with mermaids as a whole and will watch any media that has them. Hell, I own my own tails and monofins. But every time I see a gif or a video for the new Little Mermaid, I cringe

(btw, this is NOT because of the casting. If you're against this movie because Ariel is black, you're a racist piece of shit and this post isn't for you)

My issue lies with the CGI. It just looks so FAKE. We've seen through the course of movies and TV shows that use it that CGI does not age well, and that's because technology is constantly improving. What was impressive in 2005 is not impressive in 2023 (Just look at Aquamarine, another movie about mermaids). And the CGI on Ariel and her sisters already looks fake and the movie isn't even out yet!

Compare this image from the trailer

I Want To Be Excited For The Live Action Little Mermaid So Badly

To this screenshot from H20: Just Add Water (a TV show that came out in 2006):

I Want To Be Excited For The Live Action Little Mermaid So Badly

You can see the details of the scales in the second image

The first image is flat. Sure, it's colorful, but it's flat. It's fake. Halle herself is the most beautiful and alive part of the image, because everything else is fake

The difference?

H20 had costume designers, ones specifically trained in mermaid tail making, HAND CRAFT every tail on the show. All of the scales were hand laid, all the tails molded to fit the actors/actresses perfectly, painted by hand

Let's even look at someone with no affiliation to TV or movies:

I Want To Be Excited For The Live Action Little Mermaid So Badly

This is Mermaid Linden, a very well known (in the mermaid community) professional mermaid. You can tell her tail is not as high quality as the ones made for H20 (though it's still a VERY expensive tail) - but it still looks like it's a part of her. You can still see the details. Because professional mermaid tails are also all handmade and molded to fit each person. Even if they don't lay every individual scale, good professional mermaid tail makers are very meticulous about what they do.

This is what happens when Disney refuses to pay practical effects artists. We could have had beautiful, handmade tails that would look real on screen for decades to come and could be reused for promotional purposes - instead, they're underpaying and overworking their non-unionized employees to make CGI tails that don't even look real now.

(to be clear, I'm not shitting on the artists. As I said, they're being underpaid and overworked. This is not their fault)

And before anyone comes and says "But swimming in those is difficult!" Absolutely it is. You should never swim in a professional level tail (or even just fabric tails) without practice and training. Which Disney could have given the cast if they were willing to PAY people (the cast of H20 [a TV SHOW] literally learned how to be mermaids on set. It's been done before)

Disney's "Live Action" needs to be rebranded as "CGI with some real people tossed in" because that's all any of these remakes have been, and it's exhausting when I look at what we could have had.

1 year ago

professors who have only interacted with other academics for years: “what do you MEAN you don’t know multi-variable calculus yet??”

professors with small kids: “thank you for not putting the lab equipment in your mouths when I turn my back”

2 years ago

Dude has a death wish

2 years ago

Hanging out with old people rules because after a while they trust you enough to confess to murder totally unprompted

2 years ago

I just remembered this video and it just brings me so much joy


Tags
2 years ago

The funny thing is, Wilhelm for all his anxiety, and insecurities and messy personal life and raw grief is actually the best man for the job. Being king, being a leader comes naturally for him. Because it's not about being arrogant and power drunk, it's not about pulling rank. It's about using the resources you have to your advantage.

He knew exactly how to persuade his schoolmates. He knew when and how to one up August, hit him where it hurts. He knew how to negotiate, with the queen herself mind, and knew when to accept what was given. He knew when to hold his ground and he knew when to let go. It's exactly where August goes wrong all the time because he has a giant savior complex. He has to be everybody's knight in shining armor.

This anxiety riddled boy got up on stage, in front of so many important people, in front of the queen, his mother, and managed to not only take back control of his narrative, but he did it completely impromptu. This boy who didn't even want to speak in front of his class changed his initiation speech midway because he knew he had to stand up for what he believed in. The fact that he has doubts and questions his abilities, if anything makes him uniquely qualified. Because if a 16 year old, royal or not, isn't a little phased by responsibilities that heavy, then they're not the man for the job.

He's grieving the death of his brother, dealing with almost zero parental support and a backstabbing cousin. And he's a goddamn teenager. He's doing better than most people would have. And I, for one, can't wait to see crown prince Wilhelm run the show in s3.

The writers better give us a third season 🔫

2 years ago

i think about this one so fucking often i had to clip it

2 years ago
21 People Who Forgot A Word And Just Made Some Shit Up
21 People Who Forgot A Word And Just Made Some Shit Up
21 People Who Forgot A Word And Just Made Some Shit Up
21 People Who Forgot A Word And Just Made Some Shit Up
21 People Who Forgot A Word And Just Made Some Shit Up
21 People Who Forgot A Word And Just Made Some Shit Up
21 People Who Forgot A Word And Just Made Some Shit Up

21 People Who Forgot A Word And Just Made Some Shit Up

2 years ago

teenage taylor dressed up in vintage ball gowns and was shamed by men in her personal life for not being mature and then she stopped the ‘fairytale’ stories in her head to try and prove herself. now she’s made her way back into the fairytale for a song about coming out of a relationship you didn’t feel appreciated in and learning to appreciate yourself, childlike tendencies and all

image
  • mistyhorizon
    mistyhorizon liked this · 10 months ago
  • redrosesandcharmingsouls
    redrosesandcharmingsouls liked this · 1 year ago
  • ms-anne-xia
    ms-anne-xia liked this · 1 year ago
  • maryhasarrived
    maryhasarrived liked this · 2 years ago
  • siriusblacksofficaldaughter
    siriusblacksofficaldaughter liked this · 2 years ago
  • timetravelingshark
    timetravelingshark liked this · 2 years ago
  • the-misanthropic-magicalgirl
    the-misanthropic-magicalgirl reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • sofia493
    sofia493 liked this · 2 years ago
  • lady-of-the-spirit
    lady-of-the-spirit liked this · 2 years ago
  • starlight95tonight
    starlight95tonight liked this · 2 years ago
  • essenceoflaughter
    essenceoflaughter liked this · 2 years ago
  • valkyriesix
    valkyriesix liked this · 2 years ago
  • mafagafobebum
    mafagafobebum liked this · 2 years ago
  • medeatriumph
    medeatriumph liked this · 2 years ago
  • something-kinda-cool
    something-kinda-cool liked this · 2 years ago
  • sagethewarriorgoddess
    sagethewarriorgoddess liked this · 2 years ago
  • shaunaenabler
    shaunaenabler liked this · 2 years ago
  • faust-vs-mephistopheles
    faust-vs-mephistopheles reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • chogireturn
    chogireturn liked this · 2 years ago
  • sielutonlampikana
    sielutonlampikana reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • sielutonlampikana
    sielutonlampikana liked this · 2 years ago
  • mr-bottle-28-3-96
    mr-bottle-28-3-96 reblogged this · 2 years ago
  • mr-bottle-28-3-96
    mr-bottle-28-3-96 liked this · 2 years ago
  • not-so-lost-after-all
    not-so-lost-after-all liked this · 2 years ago
  • theunamedauthor23
    theunamedauthor23 liked this · 2 years ago
  • owlspirit
    owlspirit liked this · 2 years ago
  • starstrucksnowing
    starstrucksnowing liked this · 2 years ago
  • abla-soso
    abla-soso reblogged this · 2 years ago

she/they

291 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags