I Think “performative Social Justice” Is Something That Doesn’t Get Addressed Often Enough. That’s

I think “performative social justice” is something that doesn’t get addressed often enough. That’s where much of the toxicity in otherwise well-meaning circles comes from.

What I mean by “performative” social justice is basically “discourse for the sake of discourse” - argument without the purpose of persuasion, in which abstract, theoretical problems are treated as seriously as if they were real-world issues. You see it in fandom all the time. I want to stress that this isn’t directed at anyone or anything in particular. It’s something I see all the time, from all sorts of people, and while I often agree with the points they make, I think it’s ultimately a pretty destructive way of thinking.

With the right rhetoric, you can make anything sound wicked. You can bypass a lot of reasoning and nuance if you sound like you’re confident that you have the moral high-ground (that’s the whole history of politics). And heck, sometimes you do! But you have to critically examine how you came to your conclusion. Nobody wants to seem like the bad guy, especially when a foolish statement can result in instant and viral public ridicule that can circulate for months or years - a pernicious form of Death of the Author. On Tumblr, the desire to conform to a particular opinion is largely motivated by fear. The punishment for deviance is often wildly disproportionate - I think we all know a few examples of things getting way out of hand. It’s seldom in response to things that cause actual, qualifiable harm.

Is there a fix for this? Maybe not on a large scale. But individually, I think it’s important to take a step back when you see drama and ask yourself, “Is this worth it? What am I trying to accomplish? Is this the most effective approach to achieving my goal?”

You’re allowed to disapprove of things casually. You can think something is tacky, in bad taste, or otherwise objectionable without needing to justify your perspective on a grand scale of good versus evil. You don’t need to use social justice as a method of signaling, to continually reestablish to your peers that you’re the Right Kind of Person only the Wrong Kind of People would disagree with. Be sure of yourself and of your beliefs. Accept nuance. A contrary opinion on a relatively trivial matter is not a personal attack, or an opportunity to flex your righteousness. Remember that the people you disagree with are often as vulnerable and well-meaning as you are.

More Posts from Psyxe and Others

4 years ago

thinking about that WoW epidemic

4 years ago

I used to believe exactly this. A couple was two, several was seven, and a few was three.

Flashing back to when I was a child riding in a car with my grandmother in the Texas Hill Country, insisting to her that just as having “a couple” of something meant you had two of them, having “several” meant you had exactly seven

6 years ago

Your D&D class based off of your Hogwarts house

Ravenclaw: Wizard

Gryffindor: Wizard

Hufflepuff: Wizard

Slytherin: Wizard

4 years ago
We Had the Vaccine the Whole Time
The silver bullet we’ve been waiting for took all of one weekend to design.

None of the scientists I spoke to for this story were at all surprised by either outcome — all said they expected the vaccines were safe and effective all along. Which has made a number of them wonder whether, in the future, at least, we might find a way to do things differently — without even thinking in terms of trade-offs. Rethinking our approach to vaccine development, they told me, could mean moving faster without moving any more recklessly. A layperson might look at the 2020 timelines and question whether, in the case of an onrushing pandemic, a lengthy Phase III trial — which tests for efficacy — is necessary. But the scientists I spoke to about the way this pandemic may reshape future vaccine development were more focused on how to accelerate or skip Phase I, which tests for safety. More precisely, they thought it would be possible to do all the research, development, preclinical testing, and Phase I trials for new viral pandemics before those new viruses had even emerged — to have those vaccines sitting on the shelf and ready to go when they did. They also thought it was possible to do this for nearly the entire universe of potential future viral pandemics — at least 90 percent of them, one of them told me, and likely more.

As Hotez explained to me, the major reason this vaccine timeline has shrunk is that much of the research and preclinical animal testing was done in the aftermath of the 2003 SARS pandemic (that is, for instance, how we knew to target the spike protein). This would be the model. Scientists have a very clear sense of which virus families have pandemic potential, and given the resemblance of those viruses, can develop not only vaccines for all of them but also ones that could easily be tweaked to respond to new variants within those families.

[…]

According to Florian Krammer, a vaccine scientist at Mount Sinai, you could do all of this at a cost of about $20 million to $30 million per vaccine and, ideally, would do so for between 50 and 100 different viruses — enough, he says, to functionally cover all the phylogenies that could give rise to pandemic strains in the future. (“It’s extremely unlikely that there is something out there that doesn’t belong to one of the known families, that would have been flying under the radar,” he says. “I wouldn’t be worried about that.”) In total, he estimates, the research and clinical trials necessary to do this would cost between $1 billion and $3 billion. So far this year, the U.S. government has spent more than $4 trillion on pandemic relief. Functionally, it’s a drop in the bucket, though Krammer predicts our attention, and the funding, will move on once this pandemic is behind us, leaving us no more prepared for the next one. When he compares the cost of such a project to the Pentagon’s F-35 — you could build vaccines for five potential pandemics for the cost of a single plane, and vaccines for all of them for roughly the cost of that fighter-jet program as a whole — he isn’t signaling confidence it will happen, but the opposite.

[…]

If we do all that, he says, the entire timeline could be compressed to as few as three months. The production and distribution of a vaccine adds considerable cost, bureaucracy, and even some chaos, as we’re likely about to see. But three months from the design of the Moderna vaccine was April 13. The second and third surges, the return to school and the long-dreaded fall, 225,000 more deaths and 50 million more infections — all of that still lay ahead. Shave another month off somehow and you’re at March 13, the day the very first person in New York City died.

The “Beau Biden Cancer Moonshot“ authorized $1.8 billion over seven years for cancer research in 2016, don’t know what he’s planning on doing as president but this would be an excellent use of research money,  Wouldn’t say no to both though.

5 years ago

i think the weirdest thing about the shelter-in-place has been the nightly howl, which i forget about every night until i’m walking my dog and the neighbors just suddenly start fucking howling.

4 years ago
I’ve Been Reading About Werewolves On Wikipedia And I Just Have To Say. “Werewolves Are Warriors

I’ve been reading about werewolves on Wikipedia and I just have to say. “Werewolves are warriors that descend into hell to fight demons” kicks unbelievable amounts of ass as a concept

5 years ago

ultisols said: wxke af

broke: woke

woke: wxke

5 years ago

 Earlier today I was inventing a conspiracy theory that the whole “Parents Are Useless” trope in children’s fiction is secretly meant to prepare us for that eventuality (it eventually lost out to the Anthropic Principle of Parental Uselessness, where out of all possible fictional universes, only the ones where parents are useless produce viable children’s stories)

the trouble with parents who expect absolute obedience from their children is that even if the parent was right all the time (already laughable) there will eventually come a day when their faculties begin to fail and the children must step in; it helps to lay the groundwork for that sooner rather than later.

9 years ago

Buy a shirt; help old dogs have a home

Old Friends Senior Dog Sanctuary provides a home for senior dogs that cannot find people to adopt them—a real home, with beds

image

 and couches for them 

image

and love and vet care and a large property to roam on with custom-made boardwalks with ramps to make it easy for the dogs that have trouble with stairs. They also provide temporary and permanent foster homes for many more, with a unique thing called Forever Fostering, where people within 100 miles of the Sanctuary can foster a dog forever, with all veterinary care and medication paid for. 

They have around 20 dogs living in the Sanctuary, including blind pug Bugsy, who had to have his eyes removed.

image

three bonded pairs, such as Harley and Smily, surrended to a shelter when their lifetime owner had to move into an assisted living facility, which the Sanctuary took in together so they would not be separated

image

and new bffs

image

And they’re having a t-shirt sale to raise funds to keep taking care of these old dogs that have been abandoned or are too old to be considered “adoptable.” And you should give them your money. 

Buy a nice shirt. Help a nice dog.

Signal boost this, and I will buy a shirt for someone randomly chosen from the list of people who reblog this post.

image

https://www.bonfirefunds.com/life-is-good-at-ofsds

7 years ago

I am coming for all the monsters that ever touched him, I am coming for all the ones who twisted his stars into shadows, They turned him into a nightmare, So I’m going to be theirs.

and they’ll never wake up // k.s. (via worthystevie)

  • caranthira
    caranthira reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • rpggameslover
    rpggameslover liked this · 1 year ago
  • ominous-meme
    ominous-meme liked this · 1 year ago
  • thesunisgonnaeatyou
    thesunisgonnaeatyou liked this · 1 year ago
  • wonderer125blog
    wonderer125blog liked this · 2 years ago
  • iceapocalypse
    iceapocalypse liked this · 2 years ago
  • thewakalix
    thewakalix reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • thewakalix
    thewakalix liked this · 3 years ago
  • cakesword
    cakesword reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • zwergnovaleuchten
    zwergnovaleuchten liked this · 3 years ago
  • applepie4
    applepie4 liked this · 3 years ago
  • thatpratdragonlady
    thatpratdragonlady reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • ante--meridiem
    ante--meridiem liked this · 3 years ago
  • occlusivavelare
    occlusivavelare reblogged this · 3 years ago
  • occlusivavelare
    occlusivavelare liked this · 3 years ago
  • koushirouizumi
    koushirouizumi reblogged this · 4 years ago
  • catboykiryu
    catboykiryu liked this · 4 years ago
  • littletinythings
    littletinythings liked this · 4 years ago
  • natarisaru
    natarisaru liked this · 4 years ago
  • zambiescooby
    zambiescooby reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • vicruls-moved
    vicruls-moved liked this · 5 years ago
  • thatisnotthowtheforceworks
    thatisnotthowtheforceworks reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • thatisnotthowtheforceworks
    thatisnotthowtheforceworks liked this · 5 years ago
  • pearlpoet-archive
    pearlpoet-archive reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • mauvehyacinth
    mauvehyacinth reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • mauvehyacinth
    mauvehyacinth liked this · 5 years ago
  • saphirachrysalis
    saphirachrysalis liked this · 5 years ago
  • piranhadrama
    piranhadrama liked this · 5 years ago
  • wilderminds
    wilderminds liked this · 5 years ago
  • schaeferlusaque
    schaeferlusaque reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • rosalietranier
    rosalietranier liked this · 5 years ago
  • thundersnowstorm
    thundersnowstorm reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • unlace
    unlace reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • whyhellotheregandalf
    whyhellotheregandalf liked this · 5 years ago
  • lessawildmoon
    lessawildmoon reblogged this · 5 years ago
  • cylon-angel
    cylon-angel liked this · 5 years ago
  • switchblade-collector
    switchblade-collector liked this · 5 years ago
  • transgeralt
    transgeralt reblogged this · 6 years ago
  • gnilsia
    gnilsia liked this · 6 years ago
  • sertaline-official
    sertaline-official reblogged this · 6 years ago
  • dlank
    dlank liked this · 6 years ago
  • vaurien
    vaurien liked this · 6 years ago
  • acrystalbirdie
    acrystalbirdie liked this · 6 years ago
  • enthusiasun
    enthusiasun reblogged this · 6 years ago
  • sunflowerdigs
    sunflowerdigs liked this · 6 years ago
psyxe - Space Whale Aesop
Space Whale Aesop

help, i made a tumblr

280 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags