We’ve had this conversation a few times.
-when I told her I knew she fucked my roommate in college.
-about 6 months later, the morning after him and I fucked her brains out after a football game.
-after she seduced her current fuck buddy while I listen after he’d thought I passed out.
The answer has always been, “I love you even more AND you’ve never been sexier to me.”
“OK babe, he just texted. He’s downstairs. It’s time for you to leave. I’ll call you in the morning when we’re done.”